Last week my son was subjected to a search for the privilege of riding the MetroRail.  This week we find out that we are subjected to surveillance in the City of Buffalo by 50 video cameras. 

Mayor Byron W. Brown, standing beneath the state-ofthe- art device, insisted the cameras will not be used for any questionable activities. They are being set up strictly to deter crime, the mayor promised.

Of course, Mayor Brown has no intention of stopping at 50 cameras.  Next we will probably be subjected to the command of “Papers Please” as we go about our business in the city.

Of course the government will do no wrong and use the video equipment for nefarious purposes.  How could we possibly think that could happen in a land where our phone calls and emails are already subjected  to the prying eyes of the government.  Mayor Brown’s assertions are empty.  The temptation will exist and some government official will misuse the video surveillance.  It is only a matter of time.  The slippery slope has begun.

One study by the Civil Liberties Union cites a 2003 report by the U.S. General Accounting Office that concluded there wasn’t enough data to gauge the effectiveness of surveillance cameras when it comes to reducing crime.

But Police Commissioner H. McCarthy Gipson said his department’s review of the technology has reached a different conclusion. Local law enforcers visited Chicago to inspect its elaborate camera system.

Naturally, the Police Commissioner is in favor of the video cameras.  Police never feel like they have enough power.  It would make much more sense, and save money, to have more police out of their cars and walking a beat.  That would increase their knowledge about what is happening in the neighborhoods and improve the relations with the community.  That would be a win-win situation without involving privacy issues.

Cameras that can see through clothing, building materials and automobiles are not far off.  Will they be next in use by the police?  Benjamin Franklin summed up the issue best, “Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.”

The Buffalo News: Home: City installs cameras in effort to prevent crime